Valentine’s Day has a bit of a reputation. Overpriced roses wrapped in plastic, cards that get tossed the next day, gifts that feel more like an obligation than an expression of love. But it doesn’t have to be that way.
For me, a sustainable Valentine’s Day isn’t about doing less, it’s about doing it differently. More meaning, less waste. More thought, fewer things that end up in a drawer by March. And honestly, the gifts that have meant the most to me over the years are the ones that didn’t come from a big-box store.
Here’s how I actually do Valentine’s Day sustainably, broken down into categories that make gifting feel fun, personal, and intentional.
Experiences (My Personal Favorite)
If you take one thing from this, let it be this, experiences > stuff.
Some of my favorite gifts I’ve ever received weren’t things at all. One year, my friends surprised me with concert tickets to see Hozier. We all went together, it turned into a full night out, and I still think about that experience way more than any physical gift.
My boyfriend and I do this too. For some anniversaries and Valentine’s Days, we’ve skipped gifts altogether and put that money toward a trip. Even a short getaway feels more special than exchanging things we don’t really need.
Experience gift ideas that always hit:
- Tickets to a local lecture, author talk, or live podcast recording
- A food-focused experience, tasting menus, dessert crawls, or a farmers’ market date with a set budget
- Outdoor experiences like guided hikes, kayaking, or bike rentals
- Creative experiences at home, paint-and-wine nights, film photography walks, or DIY pasta nights
- Memberships or passes that encourage repeat outings, climbing gyms, art houses, or community studios
You’re gifting time together, and that’s kind of the whole point.
Thrifted & Vintage Gifts (The Most Thoughtful Option)
Secondhand gifts get such an unfair reputation. Thrifting actually forces you to slow down and think about the person you’re shopping for, which is what makes it romantic in the first place.
I love gifting vintage because it’s one-of-a-kind and already exists, which means no new resources and no copy-paste gifts.
What I look for while thrifting:
- Vintage jewelry or watches
- Books with beautiful covers or handwritten inscriptions
- Leather bags, scarves, or silk ties
- Home items like vases, frames, or cocktail glasses
- Records, cameras, or collectibles tied to someone’s interests
It shows effort. It shows intention. And no one else has the same gift.
Home Goods (Practical but Still Cute)
Some of the most-used gifts I’ve received or given fall into this category. Practical doesn’t have to mean boring.
A lot of my own sustainability journey started with simple home swaps. Reusable paper towels were one of the first changes I made, they’re cheaper long-term, easy to wash, and way less wasteful. Same with reusable food storage bags, which I use constantly.
I’m also a very intense plant mom, borderline overbearing, and fully aware that my biggest flaw is overwatering. My brother clearly knows this about me, which is why he gifted me a snake plant. I named her Medusa.
He specifically chose a plant that’s notoriously hard to kill, then gave me very clear care instructions, which I’m doing my absolute best to follow. So far, so good, and yes, I am resisting the urge to water her “just in case.”
Plants are such an underrated gift, especially when paired with a beautiful pot or a self-watering planter for people who travel. They’re thoughtful, long-lasting, and way more personal than another candle.
Home gift ideas I actually love:
- Linen napkins or table runners that make everyday meals feel intentional
- Secondhand trays or catch-alls for keys, jewelry, or bedside clutter
- Good-quality dish brushes, soap dispensers, or sink caddies that upgrade a routine
- Cozy throw blankets or floor pillows for reading and lounging corners
- Small lamps or warm-light bulbs that instantly change the vibe of a space
Wellness Gifts (Things People Will Actually Use)
When I think about wellness gifts, I think about items that gently encourage better habits without being preachy.
I’ve gifted reusable water bottles to friends and my boyfriend more times than I can count. We’re humans, we need water, and having one on hand means fewer plastic bottles.
Sustainable skincare is another go-to, there are so many ethical, refillable, low-waste brands now that make great gifts.
I also love gifts that support movement or rest. Things like a yoga mat, a meditation class, or even a movie subscription feel genuinely nurturing, not just nice to have.
One of my all-time favorite subscriptions is AMC Stubs. It’s around $25 a month, you can see up to four movies a week, and my boyfriend and I are constantly using it. I’ve even convinced friends to join so we can go together. Genuinely one of the best “experience-meets-wellness” gifts out there.
Wellness gift ideas:
- Sleep-friendly gifts like silk eye masks, weighted blankets, or magnesium spray
- Journals, planners, or guided reflection books for low-pressure mindfulness
- High-quality socks, slippers, or cozy layers that encourage real rest
- Digital detox tools like screen-time lock boxes or analog alarm clocks
- Experience gifts that build a routine, sauna passes, float therapy, or sound baths
DIY Gifts (The Most Personal Option)
DIY gifts are my soft spot. When you make something with your hands, people feel that. They’re way less likely to toss it, and way more likely to keep it for years.
Some of my favorite gifts ever were handmade. One friend made clay magnets customized to each of our personalities, and they’re still on my fridge. I also love crafting things like bookmarks from old magazines or paper scraps, especially for book-lover friends.
Lately, I’ve been obsessed with making small ribbon bows using leftover ribbon I’ve collected over the years. I also bought a button maker off eBay, which has become one of my favorite creative outlets. I design custom buttons for friends based on their interests, it’s inexpensive, personal, and fun.
DIY gift ideas:
- Customized playlists paired with handwritten liner notes
- Thrifted frames with a printed photo, ticket stub, or inside joke
- Recipe cards featuring family favorites or “comfort meals” you love
- Handmade candles or incense blends using scents you know they like
- Little “open when” letters for different moods or moments
Don’t Forget the Wrap
You can give the most thoughtful gift in the world and still wrap it in something that goes straight to the trash.
I always try to reuse what I already have or wrap gifts in fabric, scarves, or brown paper dressed up with twine or dried flowers. It doesn’t need to be perfect, it just needs to not be single-use plastic.
The Takeaway
A sustainable Valentine’s Day isn’t about being anti-gift or anti-romance. It’s about choosing things that last longer than February 14.
Experiences over clutter. Vintage over mass-produced. Thought over trends.
And honestly, that feels way more romantic anyway. 💘
- Instagram: @lexysilverstein
- Youtube: Lexy Silverstein
- Twitter: @eLEXYfy
- TikTok: @lexysilverstein
- Facebook: Lexy Silverstein
- Liketoknow.it/lexysilverstein
You can email me at LexySilverstein@gmail.com
